![the phantom of the opera movie gerard butler the phantom of the opera movie gerard butler](https://i.pinimg.com/originals/f7/c1/19/f7c119779859001765bc32c85c290bc4.jpg)
![the phantom of the opera movie gerard butler the phantom of the opera movie gerard butler](https://i.pinimg.com/originals/e8/9f/fc/e89ffc723ffb14c736582b0decdae68e.jpg)
However I think it can be looked at with a different interpretation from the movie's perspective.įor instance, he does still have a rather major deformity (admittedly the film's lighting minimizes it sometimes and it is not as intense as the stage version). In regards to what the plot requires, I agree with you that concept of the Phantom is of a horrific individual who uses his singing and charisma (and false pretenses) to manipulate a girl to fall in love with him. Would genuinely like to hear others' thoughts! His voice was approved by Andrew Lloyd Webber himself and falls more in line with the "Rock n roll" aesthetic that Webber had originally intended for the role to have. Rewatch the entirety of "Down Once More" (particularly the second half) and tell me that he's ever reached that level of both insanity and heartbrokenness in any role since. Gerard Butler gives the performance of his career in this role. Butler's gritty baritone can get both surprisingly soft and timid, but naturally sits in a more baritone register, leading to a character who could more believably both seduce a young woman and strike fear in the hearts of the Opera House populace. I'm sorry, but Michael Crawford, Peter Joback and other phantoms frequently sound almost childlike, with true tenor registers. His Phantom is more masculine/aggressive. His character's singing doesn't have to be great because that's not where his genius lies. Just like a football coach who knows the game but can't tackle a linebacker. The character of the Phantom in the film is a musical prodigy when it comes to writing and teaching, not necessarily to singing execution. Here's where we get to the different part. His character never had any formal training. While his singing is not remotely precise, his transitions from mysterious to sexy to haunted to broken to terrifying to pitiful are truly remarkable, and the subtlety of some of his acting moments are something that is often nonexistent in the technique-heavy dramatic Broadway performances. His Phantom has more emotional range than any other.
![the phantom of the opera movie gerard butler the phantom of the opera movie gerard butler](https://i.pinimg.com/originals/78/56/44/785644b69e8924824ade73142d063258.jpg)
I've yet to hear anyone share my opinion on this so here goes: Gerard Butler played an amazing (albeit different) phantom in the 2004 film adaptation of Phantom of the Opera.